Philadelphia, Pennsylvania — Federal and state prosecutors have announced charges against 19 individuals accused of participating in multiple schemes that allegedly defrauded Pennsylvania’s Medicaid program of more than $4 million through false home health care billing records.
According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, the defendants include home care company owners, home health aides, and Medicaid recipients, all accused of submitting fraudulent claims for services that prosecutors say were never provided.
Prosecutors Allege Widespread Medicaid Billing Fraud
Authorities say the alleged schemes relied on false timesheets, fabricated clock-in and clock-out records, overlapping work shifts, and kickback payments to Medicaid recipients.
Investigators claim several home health aides billed Medicaid for patient care while they were incarcerated, hospitalized, traveling abroad, working other jobs, or otherwise unavailable to provide care.
Federal officials described what they called recurring examples of “impossible work hours,” suggesting some caregivers claimed to work far beyond what would be physically possible.
One Aide Allegedly Claimed More Than 64,000 Impossible Work Hours
Among the most significant allegations is a case involving a home health aide who prosecutors say claimed to provide care for more than 24 hours in a single day on over 1,100 occasions.
According to investigators, the aide submitted claims for more than 64,000 work hours that could not have been performed, resulting in over $1.2 million in Medicaid payments.
Announcing the charges, U.S. Attorney David Metcalf condemned the alleged fraud.
He said it was unacceptable for individuals to bill taxpayers for nonexistent home care services, including situations where caregivers were allegedly dead, in prison, or involved in criminal activity instead of providing patient care.
Multiple Defendants Face Separate Fraud Allegations
Federal prosecutors filed several indictments involving different groups of defendants across the Philadelphia area.
One indictment charges Joseph Pizzo, 47, and Tiziana Taormina, 52, alleging Medicaid claims were submitted for home care services while Pizzo was incarcerated and also while he was working in construction. Prosecutors estimate the alleged scheme generated at least $160,000 in Medicaid payments.
Another indictment accuses Donna Romsteadt, 63; Alyssa Cuculino, 27; Louise Israel, 46; and Elexis Cuculino, 51 of participating in another fraudulent billing scheme.
Investigators allege Alyssa Cuculino billed Medicaid while working another job or while hospitalized, while Louise Israel allegedly submitted claims during periods when she was in jail. Prosecutors say those claims totaled approximately $445,000.
Investigators Cite Fraud During Overseas Travel and Other Activities
Authorities also charged Albert Coccia Jr., 56, and Santino Coccia, 28, alleging Santino billed Medicaid for caring for his father while simultaneously working as a ride-share and food-delivery driver. Prosecutors say the alleged fraud exceeded $211,000.
In another indictment, Sean Murray, 58, is accused of billing Medicaid roughly $400,000 for home care services while allegedly visiting the gym, traveling, going to a massage parlor, or selling drugs. Prosecutors also allege he paid kickbacks to Medicaid recipients to facilitate the scheme.
Meanwhile, Charles Bowie, 53, allegedly submitted Medicaid claims while traveling internationally, including trips to Saudi Arabia, Jamaica, and Colombia.
Authorities estimate approximately $600,000 in billings were connected to that case, with prosecutors alleging most of the claims were fraudulent.
Home Health Company Owners Also Charged
Federal prosecutors also charged Benevolent Home Health LLC and its owners, Khaleelah Williams, 49, and Saleemah Davis, 29, with health care fraud conspiracy and wire fraud.
According to investigators, the company allegedly obtained approximately $224,000 in Medicaid payments by submitting fraudulent claims.
Prosecutors further allege the business billed Medicaid for services supposedly performed by Williams’ husband while he was allegedly selling drugs and after his arrest on drug trafficking charges. Authorities also claim the company billed for services allegedly provided by a home health aide who had already died.
The criminal cases are ongoing, and all defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
What are your thoughts on this case?
Do you believe stronger oversight is needed to prevent Medicaid fraud and protect taxpayer-funded health care programs? Share your opinion in the comments below.
